Whispers in the Well introduces power creep to Disney Lorcana in a way that hasn’t been done before. Some of the strongest cards the game has seen since launch have made their way into the card pool, bringing unexpected combinations and new features to colors that haven’t seen them before.
Whispers in the Well makes a lot more ink color combinations viable, and brings some truly powerful landmark cards to the forefront. On top of that, we’ve finally got Gargoyles and The Black Cauldron making their way into the game, bringing fan favorite and cult following titles to the forefront. Which cards are the best and most valuable from this set, though?
Prices are based on the current market value of cards on TCGPlayer.com
The Headless Horseman, Terror Of Sleepy Hollow (Enchanted) – $123
Medusa Memories Abound
If you’ve been playing Disney Lorcana for a while, you might recall Madame Medusa, who had a similar effect on play. The Headless Horseman, Terror of Sleepy Hollow, has a very good on-play ability to banish every character with two strength or less.
When doing this, you strengthen your already strong characters since you’re playing Ruby, potentially creating a very scary board state for your opponent to stare down. Not only is the card good, but the artwork takes Disney Lorcana into a darker style, truly embracing some of the scarier and thrilling artwork the game has to provide.
Malicious, Mean, And Scary (Enchanted) – $133
A Song For A Dangerous Combo
Malicious, Mean, and Scary sets up several combination pieces for Emerald cards, bringing new life to options that haven’t seen play since release. Dropping one damage counter on every opposing character can have huge ramifications, especially with so many viable combinations of cards that affect already damaged characters.
Add to this that it’s a relatively inexpensive Song, and you can have your character sing it to deal damage to every opposing character on the field. It’s a surprising new addition to the game that’s definitely going to see lots of play in Emerald.
Can’t Hold It Back Anymore (Enchanted) – $154
Let It Go, Let It Go
One of the most unique aspects about this card is that it does something new in the game, combining other effects to make something greater. Not only that, but it’s a continuation of a song, and it’s quite beautiful to boot.
Like most of the Amethyst cards in the set, this Enchanted card uses the purple and blue to a unique and gorgeous effect, making a beautiful collector’s item. Couple this with the ablity to move all damage and potentially send a character to the discard pile, and it’s easy to see why it’s so valuable.
Webby Vanderquack, Junior Prospector (Enchanted) – $155
Warded Ramp In An Adorable Package
Webby Vanderquack, Junior Prospector, is sure to see a lot of play this set. One of the better Legendary cards, Emerald gets some additional ramp with Webby, while also tackling the issue of going second in a game.
If you can shift her in early, you can even the playing field for going after your opponent. She also quests for two, has some decent stats, and has Ward. The artwork is adorable but the playability truly shines, making her quite a valuable card to play.
Spooky Sight (Enchanted) – $180
Welcome Back Selective Board Wipe
The card we’ve all been waiting for. A decent board wipe option has finally arrived with Spooky Sight, and it’s giving Sapphire some fun options to play with regarding removal. Amber should be very afraid with Spooky Sight hiding in Sapphire decks.
We’re all looking for some form of removal, and this card is not only giving us that, but it’s such a great classic artwork as well. The art evokes that Halloween Disney feel and brings back memories of the Headless Horesman and the main Disney three.
Goliath, Clan Leader (Enchanted) – $184
A Tricky Gargoyle To Play
It seems gargoyles are pretty popular, as another Enchanted Gargoyle makes the most valuable list. Goliath also has some amazing artwork that completely differentiates it from the regular version of the card, evoking a completely different emotion and making the card art shine.
This card is also very playable but a bit tricky. In the best condition, you can empty your hand after ramping and draw two cards while forcing your opponent to discard a more full hand.
Demona, Scourge Of The Wyvern Clan (Enchanted) – $232
A Dangerous Gargoyle Villain Rises Up
An unexpected face makes the list of the most valuable cards, and it’s a Gargoyle. Demona, the Gargoyle villainess herself, is one of the most valuable cards in Whispers in the Well in her enchanted version.
While she’s a popular legendary card on her own, the Enchanted version gives her the villain look we all remember, with blazing eyes and a menacing demeanor while perched. Another very playable card with good stats and a powerful ability allowing you to exert all other characters, she’s valuable in both monetary value and actual play.
Cinderella, Dream Come True (Enchanted) – $328
Potentially The Most Powerful Card This Set
Cinderella always seems to get not only beautiful cards but also very good mechanical cards. Not only is this Enchanted artwork gorgeous, but it also evokes that classic Disney feel. On top of this, Cinderella, Dream Come True is actually a very good card in itself. Not only are you able to ramp when you play her, but you also get to draw a card.
The best part about her is that she triggers herself. On play, she’s a serious threat, providing card draw, giving you more ink, and she stacks with other copies of Cinderella, Dream Come True. The only reason she isn’t the most expensive is that there are Iconic cards in the set.
Ariel, Ethereal Voice (Iconic) – $700
Ariel Doing What She Does Best
There are only our Iconic cards in existence, so it’s no surprise that one of the most expensive cards is an Iconic, and of course, it’s a Disney princess. Ariel, Etehereal Voice is definitely high in price due to its artwork and the fact that it’s an Iconic card, the highest rarity in the game now.
Her effect is ok, as she’s one of the new Whisper cards introduced. She revolves around singing, but it gives card draw to Amber, where it’s desperately needed. The special foiling, the lore pips across the card, there’s so much making this card beautiful that it’s no surprise it’s so expensive.
This is based on her current sale cost average, as the market value has not been completely established yet.
Hades, Looking For A Deal (Iconic) – $715
A Pretty Sweet Deal For Someone
Always scheming, Hades joins the ranks of the most valuable cards in Whispers in the Well. Hdes, A Pretty Sweet Deal comes in as an Iconic card rarity, the first Iconic villain, and as a pretty solid ability overall. You can effectively get rid of a character or draw two cards, both great outcomes for you, and a deal your opponent has to make at the same time.
The card is gorgeous, with deep purple and blue hues, intricate frame breaking, and it’s a high rarity card that’s highly playable as well. It’s definitely a valuable card overall.
